Updated 17 October 2026 · HabitatCue Editorial Team
Bearaby vs Riley
Bearaby
No. 5 of 123 in bedding and sheets9.2Pick Bearaby for a lower entry price ($39 against $119) and a lower free-delivery threshold ($0 against $100).

Riley
No. 11 of 123 in bedding and sheets8.7Pick Riley for a longer return window (60 days against 30 days).
Key differences
- Bearaby scores higher overall: 9.2 against 8.7.
- Bearaby has a lower entry price ($39 against $119).
- Riley has a longer return window (60 days against 30 days).
- Bearaby has a lower free-delivery threshold ($0 against $100).
- Among products, only Bearaby offers Weighted blankets.
Side by side
Riley | ||
|---|---|---|
| Cost | ||
| Price from | $39Lowerin the lowest quarter of 97 brands | $119above the median of 97 brands |
| Free delivery threshold | $0at the median of 92 brands | $100in the highest quarter of 92 brands |
| Sleep trial | 0 nightsin the lowest quarter of 131 brands | Not listed |
| Certifications | Oeko-Tex, GOTS, Fairtrade | Not listed |
| Other facts | ||
| Products | Sheets, Duvet covers, Pillows, Weighted blankets | Sheets, Duvets, Duvet covers, Pillows, Towels |
| Materials | Cotton, Bamboo | Cotton, Linen |
| Markets | United States, Canada | United States |
| Return window | 30 daysat the median of 164 brands | 60 daysHigherabove the median of 164 brands |
| Company | ||
| Headquarters | United States | Not listed |
| Support channels | Email, Help centre | Email, Help centre |
Our verdict on each
Bearaby
Bearaby suits shoppers in the US and Canada who want certified bedding across sheets, duvet covers, pillows and weighted blankets from a single seller. Entry pricing of $39 and a return window of 30 days make it an easy first order in the bedding range.
Read the full Bearaby reviewRiley
Riley suits US shoppers building a full bed, from sheets to duvet covers to pillows and towels, all in cotton and linen. Its 60 days return window runs ahead of the field, though entry prices of $119 sit well up the market.
Read the full Riley reviewIf neither fits
How they place
- Pillows and mattress toppers
- Bearaby 7 of 79 by score · Riley 14 of 79 by score
Pros and cons
Bearaby
Pros
- Delivery is free on every order, because the free delivery threshold is $0
- The range spans sheets, duvet covers and pillows, so a whole bed can come from a single seller
- Materials listed are cotton and bamboo, so a reader can move between a classic weave and a plant based one
Cons
- Duvets and toppers are not among its product types, so a filled duvet or a topper has to come from elsewhere
- Linen, wool, down and silk are not among its materials
- The range reaches US and CA only, so buyers in other countries need a different seller
Riley
Pros
- Returns run 60 days, ahead of the field and well past the typical window most rivals work to
- One store covers sheets, duvets, duvet covers, pillows and towels, so a whole bed can be ordered together
- Materials stay to cotton and linen, which covers both a cool percale-style feel and a softer linen one
Cons
- Entry prices of $119 make Riley one of the costlier options in the category, so a budget build looks elsewhere
- Shipping covers US only, which rules Riley out for anyone shopping outside the US
- Support runs on email and help centre alone, so there is no phone line for urgent delivery questions
Who each suits
Bearaby
Who it suits
- Households in the US and Canada buying certified bedding in a compact range
- Shoppers who want sheets, duvet covers and pillows ordered together from a single seller
Who should look elsewhere
- Shoppers who want a filled duvet or a topper from a single seller, who should look at Coop Sleep Goods, whose types run to sheets, duvets and duvet covers
- Shoppers who want a topper alongside their sheets, who should compare Blackroll BNL, whose range of sheets, pillows and toppers pairs bedding with toppers
- Shoppers after linen, wool or down, who should start with CuddleCo and its bedding list of sheets, duvets and pillows
Riley
Who it suits
- US shoppers replacing a full bed in one order, across sheets, duvets, duvet covers, pillows and towels
- Anyone who prefers to work in cotton and linen and wants both cotton and linen options
- Buyers who put a long returns window ahead of a low entry price, and who would rather live with a set than decide quickly
Who should look elsewhere
- Shoppers on a tight budget, who will find cheaper entry prices outside Riley
- Anyone outside US, who will not find Riley shipping to them
- Anyone after toppers, who should look at Coop Sleep Goods or Blackroll BNL instead, since toppers are not among Riley’s product types
Current offers
Bearaby
No offer terms recorded
Riley
Discount code
15% off your first order (newsletter signup)
Email signup for the Riley Circle newsletter on the brand's own site.
Source, checked 30 September 2026
Questions about each
Bearaby
How much does Bearaby cost to begin with?
The range is listed from $39. That is the entry point a first order is measured against, and delivery is not added on top, because the free delivery threshold is $0. There is no separate renewal or subscription figure to weigh, so a later order is judged on the same starting price.
What are the return terms, and is there a sleep trial?
The return window is 30 days and the separate trial period is 0 nights, so the range does not add a sleep trial on top of ordinary returns. You decide on comfort inside the standard window, and the terms to read are the same terms a reader would find at any seller with this kind of returns policy.
Riley
What does Riley cost at entry?
Sheet sets start at $119, listed in US dollars and sorted from the cheapest set upward. That entry point places Riley towards the dearer end of the brands compared here, so it is worth pricing a full set against a single item before ordering.
How long do I have to return Riley bedding?
Riley gives 60 days for returns, which is longer than the month most of the market works to. On return days it ranks 24 of 106 brands compared, so the window is a real point of difference rather than a line in a policy page.
Sources
Bearaby
- bearaby.com: 10 facts, checked 30 September 2026
Riley
- rileyhome.com: 7 facts, checked 30 September 2026


