Your cookie choices

We use necessary cookies to make this site work. With your permission, analytics cookies help us understand usage and marketing cookies support advertising.

You can reject non-essential cookies and still use the site. Change your choices anytime in Cookie settings.

Cookie settingsCookie policy

Updated October 12, 2026 · HabitatCue Editorial Team

Bed In A Box vs Casper

Bed In A Box scores 9.3 and Casper 9.2 out of 10. Compare their differences and shared features below.
Casper

Casper

9.2/10
Visit

Bed In A Box

Higher score in this comparison

9.3/10
See alternatives

What sets them apart

Bed In A Box vs Casper
CompareBed In A BoxReviewSee alternativesSee alternativesCasperCasperReviewVisitVisit
Queen-size price$651.75Lower$899
Sleep trial (nights)120Higher100
Warranty20 yearsHigher10 years
Height (cm)27.9427.9
MarketsUSUS, CACovers more
Old mattress removalNot confirmedYes
CertificationsCertipur us, Oeko texNot confirmed

Same on both: Free delivery (Yes), Trial return fee ($0).

We earn a commission when you sign up through links on this site. Partner status can affect where a brand appears in our rankings. Partners with a live offer in your country come first, then every other brand by score.

Key differences

  • Bed In A Box scores higher overall: 9.3 vs 9.2.
  • Queen-size price is lower at Bed In A Box: $651.75 vs $899.
  • Sleep trial (nights) is higher at Bed In A Box: 120 vs 100.
  • Warranty is higher at Bed In A Box: 20 years vs 10 years.
  • Support channels: only Casper offers Email.
  • Casper is available in 1 more country.
  • Mattress types: only Bed In A Box offers Organic.
  • Firmness options: only Bed In A Box offers Firm.
  • Firmness options: only Casper offers Soft.
  • Markets: only Casper offers CA.

Our verdict on each

Bed In A Box

Bed In A Box suits readers who want a bed delivered to the door and slept on at home before deciding, since the trial runs 120 nights and the company states nothing is paid if the mattress is not satisfying. The Original queen price is $651.75.

Read the full Bed In A Box review

Casper

Casper suits buyers in the US and Canada who want a long home trial without a return charge, and it prices a queen mid pack rather than at the bottom. The trial of 100 days nights, backed by a 10 year warranty, is the reason to look here before cheaper foam options.

Read the full Casper review

Score breakdown

Bed In A Box vs Casper
AreaBed In A BoxCasper
Cost9.5HigherThe Original queen price is $651.75, and returning a mattress costs $0.9.4Queen price of $899 with a return fee of $0 and delivery at no minimum order keeps the outlay predictable.
Offer9.1Pillows come in at $24.99, and the Original stands about 27.94 cm tall in a multilayer foam build.9.1A trial of 100 nights, a 10 year warranty and old mattress removal stack up well for buyers who decide slowly.
Trust9.1The brand trades as Carpenter Co., is based in the United States, and dates its box technology to 2006.Not confirmed

How they place

Bed In A Box vs Casper
RankingBed In A BoxCasper
Mattress brands65 of 1935 of 193
Hybrid mattresses26 of 874 of 87
Memory foam mattresses28 of 865 of 86
Bedding and sheets97 of 21110 of 211
Pillows and mattress toppers70 of 18614 of 186

Every fact side by side

Bed In A Box vs Casper
FactBed In A BoxCasper
Mattress typesMemory foam, Hybrid, OrganicCovers moreMemory foam, Hybrid
Firmness optionsMedium firm, Medium, FirmSoft, Medium, Medium firm
Legal entityCarpenter Co.Casper Sleep Inc.
HeadquartersUnited StatesUnited States
Founded2006Not confirmed
Support channelsPhone, Chat, Help centreEmail, Phone, Chat, Help centreCovers more

Bedding

Bed In A Box vs Casper
FactBed In A BoxCasper
ProductsSheets, Pillows, Toppers, Weighted blanketsSheets, Duvets, Duvet covers, Pillows, Toppers, Weighted blanketsCovers more
Price from$24.99Lower$75
MaterialsBamboo, Microfiber, Memory foamCotton, Down, Microfiber
Return window120 daysHigher30 days
Free delivery threshold$0$0

Furniture

Bed In A Box vs Casper
FactBed In A BoxCasper
Delivery time (weeks)Not confirmed0
In-home trialNot confirmed100 days
Assembly includedNot confirmedNo

Where each stands against the rest

Bed In A Box vs Casper
FactBed In A BoxCasperMedian
Queen-size price$651.75lowest quarter$899below the median$1,287
Sleep trial (nights)120highest quarter100at the median100
Warranty20 yearshighest quarter10 yearsat the median10 years
Height (cm)27.94above the median27.9above the median27
Trial return fee$0at the median$0at the median$0

Median across 131 listed brands.

Pros and cons

Bed In A Box

Pros

  • Nothing is paid if the mattress is not satisfying during the 120-night trial.
  • Shipping within the contiguous United States is free, so delivery does not lift the entry price.
  • Firmness runs medium firm, medium and firm across the collection, so readers pick a feel instead of guessing.

Cons

  • Warranty cover is not the same on every model: the 20 year limited warranty does not apply to the Essential, which carries a shorter term.
  • Free delivery stops at the edge of the contiguous United States: shipping to Alaska and Hawaii comes with an additional fee, and residents of California may be subject to one, while Bed In A Box ships to the United States.
  • The 120-night trial and the 120 day return window run to the same length, so the trial adds no time beyond the return policy.

Casper

Pros

  • A trial of 100 days nights runs well past the site median of 60 nights.
  • Free delivery is included at a minimum order of $0, and old mattress removal is offered with it.
  • A warranty of 10 years sits above the site median of 5 years.

Cons

  • Assembly included: no, and the return fee is $0, so nothing in the delivery covers a frame build.
  • Casper sells into US and CA only, so buyers elsewhere sit outside its delivery and cover terms.
  • A rank of 17 out of 50 brands on queen price means the headline number is not the cheapest on the list.

Who each suits

Bed In A Box

Who it suits

  • Readers who want to sleep on the mattress at home before keeping it, given the 120-night trial.
  • Readers who want warranty cover that runs 20 years as a limited warranty.
  • Readers who want a bed brought to the door at no extra charge instead of a delivery line at checkout.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Readers shipping a bed to Alaska or Hawaii, who meet an additional delivery fee.
  • Readers who want the same warranty term on every model, since the Essential carries a shorter one.
  • Readers who want a feel much softer or much firmer than the medium-firm through firm options the collection carries.

Casper

Who it suits

  • Buyers in US and CA who want to sleep on a mattress for 100 nights before deciding.
  • Shoppers who want free delivery and old mattress removal handled on the same visit.
  • Anyone building out a full bed, since bedding covers sheets, duvets and duvet covers alongside the mattresses.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Buyers chasing the longest warranty, since Newton Baby lists lifetime cover against 10 years here.
  • Buyers who need the bed built for them, since assembly is not included at delivery; Coop Sleep Goods is the other brand in this group to compare that point against.
  • Sleepers who want a firm setting, since firmness stops at soft, medium and medium firm; Eve Sleep lists the same hybrid and memory foam builds, so feel is worth comparing there.

Country by country

Bed In A Box vs Casper
CountryBed In A BoxCasper
CanadaNoYes
United StatesYesYes

Questions about each

Bed In A Box

How much does a Bed In A Box queen mattress cost?+

The queen size of the Original mattress is $651.75, and that is the figure the brand puts forward. Pillows are the smaller outlay at $24.99 if you would rather try the brand on bedding first.

How long is the Bed In A Box trial, and what does returning a mattress cost?+

The trial runs 120 nights, and the company states buyers pay nothing if they are not satisfied. Any mattress may also be returned within 120 days of receipt for a refund, so the two windows run to the same length. The return fee is $0, with neither a restocking nor a reshipping charge added.

Casper

What does a Casper queen mattress cost?+

The Casper One foam mattress is listed at $899 for a queen, and that is the figure most comparison tables use. It sits in the middle of this group rather than at either end, so anyone who has found a lower number should weigh what the trial and warranty come with before moving across.

How long is the Casper home trial?+

The trial runs 100 nights, longer than the site median of 60 nights. Sleeping on a mattress for that stretch in your own room is the whole point of the arrangement, and the return fee is $0, so changing your mind later adds nothing to the outlay.

Other options to compare

Casper

Visit

Bed In A Box

See alternatives